The Etiquette of Sending Back Wine at Restaurants: When It's Okay and How to Do It
- Maureen Messmer
- Apr 22
- 13 min read
Updated: Jun 9
Imagine this: you've settled into a cozy restaurant, the ambiance is perfect, and you've just
ordered a bottle of wine. But when it arrives, something feels off. Perhaps it’s the aroma, the taste, or even the temperature. Sending back a wine can be daunting, especially in a formal setting, where etiquette reigns supreme. But fear not! In this guide, we’ll demystify the etiquette of sending back wine at restaurants. Discover when it's perfectly acceptable to send that bottle back and learn the grace and finesse required to do it without causing a scene. Whether you’re a wine connoisseur or an occasional sipper, knowing the ins and outs of wine etiquette will ensure your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. So, the next time a bottle arrives that doesn't meet your expectations, you'll have the confidence and know-how to address it with aplomb. Let’s raise our glasses to enjoying wine the way it’s meant to be! Whether you are at home or at a five-star bistro, you deserve wine that’s flawless—these are my go-to bottles when I want no surprises.
Understanding Wine Etiquette
Wine etiquette is a blend of tradition, respect, and an appreciation for the art of winemaking. It encompasses a range of behaviors, from how you select and taste wine to how you interact with restaurant staff when something isn’t quite right. The fundamental principle behind wine etiquette is to enhance the enjoyment of the experience for everyone involved. Being knowledgeable about wine etiquette not only shows your respect for the establishment and its employees but also demonstrates your understanding and appreciation of the wine itself.
When you order wine at a restaurant, it is customary for the server or sommelier to present the bottle to you before opening it. This allows you to verify that it is indeed the wine you ordered. They will then open the bottle and pour a small amount into your glass for you to taste. This ritual isn’t just for show; it’s an important step in ensuring the wine is in good condition. You should take a moment to check the wine’s appearance, aroma, and taste. If something seems off, this is your opportunity to address it.
Understanding this process and the reasons behind it can help you feel more comfortable and confident. Knowing what to expect and how to react can make a big difference in your overall dining experience. By following proper wine etiquette, you not only ensure your own satisfaction but also contribute to the smooth operation of the restaurant and a pleasant atmosphere for all patrons.
Common Reasons for Sending Back Wine
There are several common reasons why you might find it necessary to send back a bottle of wine. One of the most prevalent issues is cork taint, often referred to as a wine being "corked." This occurs when the wine is contaminated by a compound called TCA (trichloroanisole), which can give it a musty, moldy odor reminiscent of wet cardboard or a damp basement. Cork taint can occur in wines sealed with natural corks, affecting the aroma and flavor of the wine and making it undrinkable.
Another common issue is oxidation. This happens when wine has been exposed to too much oxygen, leading to a deterioration in quality. Oxidized wine may taste flat, dull, or overly sour, and its color can appear brownish. Oxidation can occur if the cork has failed to seal the bottle properly or if the wine has been stored improperly. Wine that has been stored at an incorrect temperature or exposed to light for extended periods can also suffer from oxidation.
Because sending wine back is one thing—but sipping something perfect the first time? Even better. Try these.
Lastly, there is the issue of temperature. Wine should be served at the correct temperature to ensure its flavors and aromas are at their best. Red wine served too warm can taste overly alcoholic, while white wine served too cold can mask its delicate flavors. If your wine is not at the correct temperature, it is perfectly reasonable to ask for it to be adjusted or replaced. Understanding these common issues will help you identify when a wine is not up to standard and needs to be addressed.
When is it Appropriate to Send Back Wine?
Knowing when it is appropriate to send back a bottle of wine is crucial to maintaining good etiquette and ensuring a pleasant dining experience. One of the key moments to assess the wine is during the initial tasting after the bottle has been opened. This is your opportunity to determine if the wine is flawed or if it meets your expectations in terms of quality and condition. If the wine is corked, oxidized, or otherwise spoiled, it is entirely appropriate to send it back at this stage.
However, it is important to distinguish between a wine that is flawed and a wine that simply does not suit your personal taste. If the wine is technically sound but you find that you do not enjoy its flavor profile, it may not be appropriate to send it back. In such cases, consider discussing your preferences with the sommelier or server before ordering to avoid this situation. They can often recommend a wine that better matches your tastes.
Avoid the awkwardness altogether. These are the wines I serve that never disappoint (and always get compliments).
Another appropriate time to send back a wine is if it is served at an incorrect temperature. Wine served too warm or too cold can significantly impact your enjoyment of it. If you find that the temperature is not right, politely request that the wine be chilled or warmed to the appropriate level. Remember, the goal is to enjoy the wine at its best, and ensuring the correct temperature is part of that experience. By understanding these guidelines, you can confidently decide when it is appropriate to send back a wine.
How to Politely Communicate Your Concerns
Communicating your concerns about a bottle of wine should be done with tact and politeness. The first step is to remain calm and composed. Remember that sending back wine is a common occurrence, and restaurant staff are trained to handle such situations professionally. Begin by making eye contact with your server or sommelier and gently explain the issue you have encountered with the wine. Use specific terms and be clear about what you perceive as the problem, whether it is cork taint, oxidation, or an incorrect temperature.
It is helpful to use descriptive language when explaining your concerns. For example, if the wine is corked, you might say, "I’m detecting a musty, off-putting odor that suggests the wine may be corked." If the wine is oxidized, you could note, "The wine tastes flat and has an unusual brownish color, which makes me think it might be oxidized." Being precise in your description helps the sommelier or server understand the issue and address it appropriately.
Throughout the interaction, maintain a respectful and courteous demeanor. Avoid using accusatory or confrontational language, as this can create unnecessary tension. Instead, frame your concerns as observations and express your desire for a positive dining experience. For instance, you might say, "I was really looking forward to enjoying this wine, but I think there might be an issue. Could we possibly choose a different bottle?" By approaching the situation with grace and respect, you can ensure a smooth resolution and continue to enjoy your meal.
The Role of the Sommelier in Wine Service
The sommelier plays a crucial role in the wine service experience at a restaurant. As a trained wine professional, the sommelier is responsible for curating the wine list, recommending wines to guests, and ensuring that each bottle is served in optimal condition. When issues arise with a bottle of wine, the sommelier is your ally in resolving the problem. Their expertise allows them to quickly identify and understand any flaws in the wine and take appropriate action.
When you express concerns about a wine, the sommelier will typically assess the situation by tasting the wine themselves. This step is important as it confirms the flaw and helps the sommelier decide the best course of action. If the wine is indeed flawed, the sommelier will replace the bottle without hesitation. Their goal is to ensure that you have a positive and enjoyable dining experience, and they are there to assist you in selecting a wine that meets your expectations.
In addition to addressing issues with the wine, the sommelier can also provide valuable guidance in choosing the right wine to complement your meal. By discussing your preferences and the dishes you have ordered, the sommelier can make recommendations that enhance the overall dining experience. Their extensive knowledge of wine and food pairings ensures that each bottle is selected with care and consideration. Trusting the sommelier’s expertise can lead to discovering new and delightful wines that you might not have chosen on your own.
Tips for Choosing the Right Wine to Avoid Issues
Selecting the right wine can help you avoid many common issues that might lead to sending a bottle back. One of the best ways to ensure a positive experience is to take advantage of the sommelier’s knowledge and expertise. When in doubt, ask for recommendations. Provide the sommelier with information about your preferences, such as the types of wines you enjoy, any particular regions or varietals you favor, and the dishes you plan to order. This allows the sommelier to suggest wines that are likely to meet your expectations.
Another tip is to familiarize yourself with the wine list before making a decision. Many restaurants provide detailed descriptions of their wines, including tasting notes, grape varieties, and regions of origin. Take the time to read these descriptions and look for wines that align with your preferences. If you are unsure about a particular wine, don’t hesitate to ask the sommelier or server for more information. They can provide additional insights that can help you make an informed choice.
Sommelier-approved? Maybe. Lady Maureen-approved? Absolutely. Here are my latest wine obsessions you’ll want in your glass.
It’s also important to consider the occasion and your dining companions when selecting a wine. If you are dining with a group, choose a wine that will appeal to a broad range of tastes. Opting for versatile and well-balanced wines can help ensure that everyone at the table enjoys the selection. Additionally, consider the price point you are comfortable with. While it’s tempting to splurge on a special bottle, there are often excellent wines available at more modest prices. By being thoughtful and deliberate in your wine selection, you can minimize the likelihood of encountering issues and enhance your overall dining experience.
Cultural Differences in Wine Etiquette
Wine etiquette can vary significantly across different cultures, and being aware of these differences can enhance your dining experience, especially when traveling or dining in international restaurants. In many European countries, for example, wine is an integral part of the meal and is often enjoyed in a more relaxed and casual manner. In France, it is common for diners to share a bottle of wine and savor it slowly throughout the meal. The French also place great importance on pairing wine with food, and it is customary to seek the sommelier’s advice to find the perfect match.
In Italy, wine is also deeply intertwined with the dining experience, but there is a strong emphasis on regional wines. Italians take pride in their local wine traditions, and it is common to choose wines from the same region as the cuisine being served. When dining in Italy, consider asking for a local wine recommendation to fully appreciate the regional flavors. Additionally, Italians often enjoy wine in a more informal setting, and it is not unusual to see diners clinking glasses and toasting to good company and good food.
Conversely, in some Asian cultures, wine is less traditionally integrated into the dining experience. In countries like Japan and China, where sake and other spirits are more prevalent, wine may be viewed as a special or luxury item. When dining in Asian restaurants, it is important to consider the local customs and preferences. For example, in Japan, it is polite to pour drinks for others at the table rather than for oneself, and this extends to wine as well. Being mindful of these cultural differences can enrich your dining experience and demonstrate your respect for the traditions of the host country. Knowledge meets experience—pair your new wine etiquette skills with this beautiful tasting journal to capture every sip.
The Impact of Sending Back Wine on Your Dining Experience
Sending back a bottle of wine can have a significant impact on your dining experience, both positively and negatively. On the positive side, addressing issues with the wine ensures that you are able to enjoy your meal to the fullest. Wine is often an integral part of the dining experience, and having a bottle that is flawed or not to your taste can detract from your enjoyment. By sending back a wine that does not meet your expectations, you are taking steps to enhance your overall experience and ensure that you are fully satisfied with your meal.
Impress your guests, delight your palate, and skip the etiquette stress. These are your pour-with-confidence picks.
However, it is important to handle the situation with care to avoid any negative impact. If not done politely and respectfully, sending back a wine can create tension or discomfort for both you and the restaurant staff. This can affect the ambiance and overall mood of your dining experience. To mitigate this, approach the situation with a calm and courteous demeanor, clearly explaining your concerns without placing blame or making accusations. This helps maintain a positive atmosphere and ensures that the issue is resolved smoothly.
Additionally, the way the restaurant handles your request to send back a wine can greatly influence your perception of the establishment. A restaurant that addresses your concerns promptly and professionally demonstrates a commitment to customer satisfaction and quality service. This can leave you with a positive impression and make you more likely to return in the future. Conversely, if the restaurant is uncooperative or dismissive, it can leave you feeling frustrated and dissatisfied. By being mindful of how you communicate your concerns and observing how the restaurant responds, you can navigate the situation in a way that enhances your overall dining experience.
Alternatives to Sending Back Wine
While sending back a bottle of wine is sometimes necessary, there are alternatives you can consider if you encounter a minor issue or if you are unsure about the wine. One option is to request a different glass or decanter for the wine. Sometimes, wine can benefit from being aerated, which can help open up its flavors and aromas. If the wine tastes a bit closed or tight, asking for a decanter and allowing the wine to breathe for a while might improve its profile. This can be a simple and effective solution without needing to send the wine back.
Another alternative is to ask for advice from the sommelier or server. If you are unsure about the wine or if it doesn’t seem to be what you expected, discussing it with the sommelier can provide clarity. They can offer insights into the wine’s characteristics and suggest ways to enhance your enjoyment of it. For instance, they might recommend pairing the wine with a specific dish from the menu that complements its flavors. This collaborative approach can lead to a more satisfying experience without the need to return the bottle.
Studying the world of wine? These are the real-world examples your tastebuds deserve.
Lastly, if the wine is not flawed but you simply do not enjoy it, consider ordering a different bottle and keeping the original one for later in the meal or for sharing with others at the table. This way, you can explore a new wine that better suits your taste while still making use of the initial bottle. This approach is particularly useful when dining with a group, as it allows for a variety of wines to be enjoyed and shared. By considering these alternatives, you can find solutions that enhance your dining experience without the need to send back the wine.
Conclusion: Enjoying Wine with Confidence
Navigating the etiquette of sending back wine at restaurants can seem daunting, but with the right knowledge and approach, it becomes a manageable and even enjoyable aspect of dining out. Understanding when it is appropriate to send back a wine, how to communicate your concerns politely, and the role of the sommelier in assisting you are all key elements in ensuring a positive experience. By being informed and respectful, you can address any issues with confidence and grace.
Choosing the right wine from the start, being aware of cultural differences in wine etiquette, and considering alternatives to sending back a bottle can all contribute to a smoother, more enjoyable dining experience. Wine is meant to be savored and enjoyed, and having the confidence to address any concerns ensures that you can appreciate it to the fullest. Whether you are a seasoned wine enthusiast or an occasional sipper, these tips and insights will empower you to handle any wine-related situation with ease.
Restaurant-level taste without the white-linen pressure—these are the wines I recommend every confident hostess have on hand.
So, the next time you find yourself at a restaurant with a bottle of wine that doesn’t quite hit the mark, remember that it is perfectly acceptable to address the issue. With the right approach, you can ensure that your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. Raise your glass with confidence, knowing that you have the knowledge and etiquette to enjoy wine the way it’s meant to be. Cheers to a delightful and satisfying wine experience!
Some links in this post are affiliate links, meaning I may earn a commission if you buy through them. Thanks for your support! Huge Hugs, LadyM
What to Look For:
Signs Your Wine May Be Flawed. When the server pours the initial tasting portion, pay attention to the smell, appearance, and first sip. A musty, wet cardboard aroma may indicate cork taint. A wine that appears brown or tastes flat might be oxidized. If the wine seems overly alcoholic or muted, it may have been served at the wrong temperature. Trust your senses—they’re your best guide.
Avoid This Common Mistake:
Confusing Personal Preference with a Flaw. Not every wine will match your personal taste—but that doesn’t mean it’s defective. Don’t send a bottle back simply because it’s more earthy, tannic, or acidic than expected. If the wine is technically sound but not your favorite, consider it a learning experience and ask the sommelier for guidance next time.
Tangent:
Why Sommeliers Swirl Wine in the Glass. That elegant swirl isn’t just for show. Swirling wine introduces oxygen, helping release the wine’s bouquet and revealing subtle aromas. It’s also a chance to observe the "legs" or "tears" that run down the glass—clues to the wine’s alcohol or sugar content. While not required, it’s a ritual that elevates the tasting process.
Surprising Fact:
Corked Wine Has Nothing to Do with Cork Bits. Many guests think a wine is "corked" if they find bits of cork floating in the glass. In reality, cork taint is a chemical compound (TCA) that causes musty, moldy aromas—even if the cork itself looks fine. Floating cork pieces are harmless; it’s the smell and taste you should judge.
Key Background:
The Ritual of the Taste Test. The small pour you receive isn’t to determine if you like the wine—it’s to check if the wine is flawed. This practice dates back centuries and ensures the guest is not served a spoiled bottle. The ritual upholds both tradition and quality assurance in wine service.
Trivia:
When a wine is described as "corked," what does this typically indicate?
A. The wine has pieces of cork floating in it
B. The bottle has been improperly sealed
C. The wine has been contaminated with a compound causing musty aromas
D. The wine has gone bad due to old age
Trivia Answer:
C. The wine has been contaminated with a compound causing musty aromas
A corked wine is contaminated by TCA (trichloroanisole), which imparts a musty, moldy smell often likened to wet cardboard or a damp basement. It’s unrelated to cork pieces in the wine and stems from mold interactions with chlorine during cork production.
Comments